Dr. Sarah L. Gibson- A Tribute

“Lives of great ones all remind us
We can make our lives sublime
And departing leave behind us
Footprints on the sands of time.”
Henry Wadsworth Longfellow (excerpt “A Psalm of Life”)

An educational pioneer, a trailblazer, the first through the wall. Dr, Sarah Gibson leaves her footprints on the educational arena in Detroit, Michigan.

Dr. Sarah Gibson Middle School Pioneer, 1927 -2014

Dr. Sarah Gibson Middle School Pioneer, 1927 -2014

During the 1970’s, American education journeyed from the school structure of the junior high school, grades 7, 8, 9 to the school structure of the middle school, grades 6, 7, 8, and of magnet schools, drawing students from across the district. In 1971, Dr. Sarah Gibson became the first principal of the Whitney Young Magnet Middle School here in Detroit, Michigan.

Meeting Dr. Gibson

I had been teaching language arts at a junior high when I met with a district level administrator about transferring to another location. He informed me there was an opening at Whitney Young Magnet Middle School; however, the principal had brokered an understanding with the district that she could interview her staff first, something unheard of at that time. Today, it is common practice.
Dr. Gibson interviewed potential staff because she wanted to make certain that they fit with her vision of a school as a learning organization. She championed onsite, ongoing professional development where staff focused on personal mastery, building a shared vision, and team learning, while other schools engaged in one time, off site approaches. In 1990, Peter Senge from Massachusetts Institute of Technology would write The Fifth Discipline: The Art and Practice of The Learning Organization, long after Dr. Gibson had retired from Detroit Public Schools and had moved on to Oakland University.

Unique Approach to Discipline

Dr. Gibson’s approach to discipline was unique. If a student was remanded to the office or decided to go on his/her own, she didn’t start with the standard, “What did you do wrong, or why did your teacher send you to the office?” Generally, her first question was, “What are you learning in math, science, etc?” Unemotionally and with a poker face, she would listen as the student attempted to explain what s/he was learning. Her guiding question was, “How much of the problem is faulty delivery of instruction which can cause off task behavior ?” Together, they would examine the student’s notebook, folders, and textbook. Later she would meet individually with the teacher to provide additional strategies for delivering a lesson.

I remember one incident where Dr. Gibson challenged my instruction. I failed a student on her book report because she had copied it from her sibling I had taught the previous year. The student immediately made tracks to Dr. Gibson’s office with big tears in her eyes. Naturally, she asked the student to explain the assignment, which I would discover later she could not to Dr. Gibson’s satisfaction do. Later when Dr. Gibson met with me, she shared that the student really didn’t understand the assignment, didn’t understand what I expected, so she resorted to cheating. She further explained that sometimes children cheat because of the way we teach or the way we fail to teach. With hurt and anger in my heart, I EXPLAINED to Dr. Gibson that I always TELL the class what I expect and I had told them what I expected with their book reports. Dr. Gibson’s nonchalant reply was, “Lorraine, if TELLING were teaching, everyone would be smart.” OUCH!

That day, I sat afterschool in my classroom with tears in MY eyes. How could I convince my boss I was in my room doing my best, giving it my all. Suddenly, it dawned on me that half of the students “got it” when I TOLD them what I expected. But it was the half that didn’t that made me look bad. So that day, afterschool, I rearranged students’ desks from single rows facing the teacher, standard industrial classroom

Industrial Classroom Be Silent, Be Obedient, Be Still and Face the Teacher

Industrial Classroom Be Silent, Be Obedient, Be Still and Face the Teacher

operating procedure at the time – silence, obedience, stillness- to a collaborative seating approach. From now on students would sit face-to-face and side-by-side and support one another.

With Dr. Gibson’s guidance we began rethinking seating arrangements in the classrooms at Whitney Young. Classes became busy and active with students talking and discussing the lesson in collaborative groups. Students gained experience in leading and in following. Thus, before the research of Johnson and Johnson, or any of the other collaborative/cooperative learning experts/researchers published their work, “collaboration, communication, and cooperation” became part of an invisible, covert curriculum at Whitney Young Magnet Middle.

Collaboration, Communication, Cooperation

Collaboration, Communication, Cooperation

Rotating Schedule
It didn’t take Dr. Gibson long to discover that first hour students didn’t always benefit from the same quality of instruction as second or third hour students. It was as if teachers practiced the lesson on the first class and the other classes throughout the day were beneficiaries of that practice. She also discovered that in the PM teachers sent the SAME students to the office. Brainstorm! Create a rotating schedule. On Monday, teachers would teach first hour students first; however, on Tuesdays, teachers would start the day with their 2nd hour students first, next teaching third hour students etc,. On Wednesdays, teachers would start the day with 3rd hour students first and then teach the 4th hour next and so on.

Dr. Gibson had a open door policy that I availed myself of frequently. I remember our confrontation after this big rotating schedule idea Dr. Gibson shared with her staff. “Dr. Gibson, you are giving these students carte blanche to attend class late or not at all,” I admonished. “Their built in excuse, I got the days or periods mixed up.” Calmly, she explained that it would work. Just give it a chance. Again, she was right. I did interact more positively in the morning with students I had previously sent to the office in the afternoon. They saw a different side of me and I saw a different side of them. And the students were on time, on task, and on target. And my delivery of instruction became more balanced. A few years ago when I visited Renaissance High School, I found that they had adopted the rotation schedule we initiated at Whitney Young.

Accountability Pioneer
During Dr. Gibson’s reign/time, the hysteria and hoopla surrounding test scores, had not yet reached the fever pitch at the school or district level that it has today. Accountability had not yet become a watch word. However, Dr. Gibson’s inner compass knew that the scores were important to gauging student achievement. Using a handheld calculator, pen, and paper, she would disaggregate the data herself. Dr. Gibson would analyze the test items to determine where the school’s instruction was weak.

Holding a whole school staff meeting, she would share with us her findings. And she would meet privately with some of us to give us pointers on how to adjust our instruction for the next year. Now a whole test data industry has sprung up around testing. Companies and consultants use software to do what Dr. Gibson did with her calculator and her brain.

The First Through the Wall
Dr. Sarah Gibson was a pioneer, the first one through the wall. We know that the first one through the wall is often bloodied. She was bloodied but unbowed. Articulately, she defended her philosophy, her beliefs with passion and vigor. She spoke truth to power, challenging the educational status quo and working diligently to maintain Whitney Young as a progressive learning center and a problem solving, problem seeking organization until her retirement from Detroit Public Schools in 1984. .If EVERY urban school had a Dr. Gibson, there would be no “So Called” achievement gap.

I acknowledge Dr. Gibson in my workbook: A Coaches Guide to Asset-Mapping Teacher Quality http://www.amazon.com/dp/0557670950/ref=rdr_ext_tmb (Available on Amazan and Barnes and Noble)

Dr. Gibson, I will miss you greatly.

Will the REAL Chief Hope Officer Please Stand?


Mayors and Teachers-Towards a New Job Description

After a long fought, strategic battle, Mike Duggan emerged as the next mayor of Detroit, a formidable job if there ever there was one. Can he turn the ship around, or point it in a new direction? Will he create a new narrative for Detroit? The city is in a blizzard and he has been elected to lead it out. Can he? Will he? More importantly, will he be allowed to?
Mr. Duggan still has another race to run. Over the next weeks, months the mayor will be battling/negotiating with Governor Rick Snyder, with Detroit Emergency Manager Kevin Orr, and with Detroit City Council to carve out a new role, a new job description for himself . Who will emerge as Detroit’s Chief Hope Officer?
ChiefHopeOfficer

Though not present at the meetings, there IS another rival for the title of Chief Hope Officer on whose recovery, survival, the city is dependent. Challenged with preparing a fast changing, globally competitive workforce, the Detroit classroom teacher, should also be at the INCLUDED in the groundbreaking narrative AND as an integral member of the transition team charged with turning around the city’s economic future. They too are in a blizzard and face similar formidable odds as they attempt to balance a critical thinking, problem solving curriculum for ALL students along with a malodorous mix of 21st century student behaviors – All without the compensation package, respect, or support of any of the other rivals for the title receive.

What Is The New Normal?
Once upon a time during the industrial economy, the prosperous era Detroiters have ever known, teachers balanced gum chewing, fighting, littering, making noises, and talking out of turn with a rote memorization and basic skills curriculum. They were backed up/supported by parents who used their prosperity to indulge their children in shopping sprees, toys, TVs, cars, vacations if they stayed on track with good grades and citizenship. However, the sun has been switched off of that economy.

Today, too many parents are jobless, helpless and lack emotional or financial resources to back up the classroom teacher or to support their children. And, today’s teacher faces a smelly mix of different classroom behaviors: assault, bullying, digital cheating, profanity, ongoing insubordination, verbal abuse while attempting to teach a more complex curriculum to ALL students.

How do we emotionally prepare and support teachers to teach a student population raised on a corrosive culture of celebrity, degrading songs, reality TV, sexually explicit videos. Too frequently, teachers must instantaneously decide, on the spot, how to handle such behaviors when presented to them in the classroom. And generally, they are not behaviors they witnessed in their classrooms when they were students.

Part of the Job

Part of the Job

What Would You Do?
Ms. Brent, a first-grade teacher walks into her classroom to witness a wiry, angelic looking six-year old writing the letters F-U-C-K on the board. She stares at him and the word. He doesn’t back down; he stares back. What should she do? What would you do? You are limited with the amount of time you have to make a decision. Thirty pairs of eyes are on you – waiting! Do you

A. Yell and banish him to a corner of the room?
B. Lecture him and the class about using such language?
C. Send him to the office/principal immediately to
be
punished/suspended?
D. Exclude him from class until you hold parent- conference to determine where he is learning such language?
E. Give him a timeout?

Towards a NEW Job Description – A New Narrative
Like a tightrope walker, today’s teacher (Chief Hope Officer) is also engaged in a high-wire balancing act. And, it is not work for the faint of heart, insecure, timid, or unsure. Today, effective teaching requires more than scholarship and dedication; it also requires extraordinary emotional competence and resilience in order to make the scores of decisions that ensure learning takes place. Today’s educator needs to know how to deescalate a situation and how not to meet challenges, confrontations with fear, tears, or uncertainty.

Teaching Is NOT for the faint of heart.

Teaching Is NOT for the faint of heart.

Daily, hourly an educator must be prepared to put out fires, to be a relentless, resourceful problem solver, to be comfortable amid an uncomfortable environment, to identify and to be able to make use of teachable moments. Today’s educator must find inventive ways to say no to inappropriate behaviors, too often without parental support or administrative backup.

A Chief Hope Officer at Work
Ms. Brent is aware that ALL classrooms include a few Jabaris- attention-seeking, power-grabbing disruptors who seek to win control of the learning experience. They seek to be the CEO of the classroom and to dominate the non-disrupting students who attend school each day with the sole goal of learning. Thinking on her feet, Ms. Brent decides to send a message to the class that she and not Jabari is the classroom’s real alpha dog, the real CEO.
With a firm and but unemotional tone, she declares “Jabari, I see you have written a new word for us on the board. Certainly, your handwriting is improving.” Jabari smiles. She continues. “And being able to write a word means that you are a writer and a reader. Turning to face her students, she instructs, “Class, we are going to have our language arts lesson now. Jabari, will you help us? We are going to discover how many words we already know that rhyme, sound like Jabari’s word. “

She pronounces and writes the letters D-U-C-K on the board, underlining the U-C-K sound in both words. She never repeats Jabari’s word and neither does he nor does the class. For the next ten minutes, the young male and the class engage in discovering rhyming words with the U-C-K sound. When the lesson ends, the teacher thanks Jabari.

With light feet and a happy heart, he skips back to his seat having been provided with the attention, belonging, competence, recognition he craves. The teacher has just aborted a power struggle, losing face, a possible suspension (with time away from his learning). Win, Win!

Will Detroit’s REAL Chief Hope Officers Please Stand, Be Recognized, and Be Supported as the Profession Is Reconceived, Reinvented, and Reoriented!

Towards A New Narrative

Towards A New Narrative